Another of CERN's many inventions!

CERN has often been the incubator for the development of innovative technologies but very few people know about the capacitive touch screens invented for the consoles of the SPS Control Room in 1973. The Bulletin interviewed their inventor, Bent Stumpe, who also developed the CERN tracker ball and the computer-programmable knob.

 

A specific goal, a lot of motivation and the technical skills to do it: that’s all you need to create something nobody else has ever done before. Back in the 1970s, the SPS was being built and its control room required the installation of thousands of buttons, knobs, switches and oscilloscopes to operate the machine. Frank Beck, newly recruited from the DD Division to be in charge of the central control hub in the SPS control room, asked Bent Stumpe for solutions to the following problem: how to build the hardware for an ‘intelligent’ system which, in just three console units, would replace all those conventional buttons, switches, etc.

In just a few days, the Danish engineer, also from the DD Division, came up with a (hand-written) proposal to build a touch screen with a fixed number of programmable buttons, a tracker ball to be used as computer-controlled pointing device and a programmable knob. Following this proposal, Bent Stumpe was recruited by the SPS Controls Group to develop the hardware.

“We had very little time to design the new system and demonstrate that both the hardware and the software could really work”, recollects Bent Stumpe. “Thanks to Chick Nichols from the CERN EP workshop, it was possible to evaporate a very thin layer of copper on a flexible and transparent Mylar sheet. This allowed us to produce the very first prototype of a capacitive touch screen.”

Very soon, Bent Stumpe and Frank Bech were able to demonstrate that the first nine-button touch screen could really work, that is, the button pushed by the user could be reliably identified. They presented it to the Management, who accepted and supported the further development work. “In the final configuration of the SPS Control Room it was decided to install three main consoles, each equipped with a 16-button touch screen”, he says. “I have read on Wikipedia that the natural lifetime of the current touch screens is about two years. The ones we developed remained in operation for more than 20 years!”

The SPS control consoles also included a tracker ball, a device that could identify  x-y movements by rolling a ball and move the cursor on the screen accordingly. Does this remind you of anything? “We can’t say that this was the forerunner of the mouse. The first mouse was also an x-y pointing device, but worked on a different mechanical and electrical principle”, Bent Stumpe explains. “The tracker ball we developed in 1973 worked on the same principle as the mice that industry developed later in the 1980s”.

The technology developed for the capacitive touch screen was immediately transferred to industry, in particular to the Danish firm Ferroperm. At CERN the touch screen was used for a number of other control applications. CERN touch screens were also used by other big laboratories.

However, despite the numerous publications on the subject by CERN and specialist reviews, the use of touch screens was limited for a number of years partly because the system needed considerable computer power, which was very expensive at the time. Later, when computer power became cheap, the same technology was taken up again, further developed, and commercialized on the very large scale we observe today, for instance in some mobile phones.

The SPS touch-screens originally developed by Bent Stumpe were in operation from 1973 until the new LHC Control Room was installed in 2008.



How does a capacitive touch-screen work?

In a capacitive touch-screen like CERN's, the touch-sensitive area of the screen (the button) is actually part of an electric circuit. When a user touches the screen with hisfinger, he changes the dielectric of the capacitor, measurable as a change in capacitance. The software calculates the differences in capacitance relative to areas on the screen that are not being touched and identifies exactly where on the screen the change occurred. This information is then used by the software to execute the desired operation.


Further reading: CERN Yellow report.

Bent Stumpe, inventeur des écrans tactiles du CERN, de la boule de commande et de la manette programmable. Il est photographié ici avec l’un des premiers écrans tactiles développés en 1973.

George Shering, chef de la section chargée du développement du contrôle central de la Division SPS. Il était l’un des principaux développeurs de NODAL, le logiciel derrière le système de contrôle de SPS, qui comprenait les écrans tactiles.
 

La mécanique et l’électronique derrière la manette programmable de Bent Stumpe.